Find 4 Star Hotels in Windley Key, FL from ￥44,222

"This resort was everything my husband and I wanted for a last minute relaxing getaway! I can’t say enough wonderful things about it! From the second we arrived, we were greeted so nicely, felt serene, and instantly relaxed. Great food options, wonderful staff, beautiful rooms, property, pool & beach all fantastic! We will definitely be back!"

"Amara Cay is beautiful. Everyone was polite and helpful. The beach and pool area were clean and relaxing. All rooms have a balcony except for room 209, which was our room and we paid for a balcony. No discount when that is what was advertised. Other than that it was wonderful."

"This is not an inexpensive resort but is a decent value. The property is huge with pools, beach, bars, and several activities (fishing pier, bikes, snorkeling gear, volleyball, etc. it is centrally located on Islamorada to restaurants and marinas. "

"Clean, quiet and spacious room. Great activities on the ocean. Amazing pool. "

"I loved this property however the $50 a day resort fee /resort fee tax and extra parking fee/additional tax on top of that is Ridiculous for what you pay!! no bonuses other then coffee and a “smoothie” which are hidden. make sure to budget another 80 in daily fees for a Marriott property. "

"Everything was lovely except I felt rushed on my departure date. A front desk representative knocked around 9am to find out what time I was leaving. If your check out policy is 11am, you should not knock on people’s door to find out what time they are planning on leaving. It doesn’t feel like a luxurious experience when you do. In addition to the early knock, the entire housekeeping staff was waiting by my front door when I checked out at 10:25. What if I wasn’t checking out at 10:25 and was...