This darling cottage was perfect for my husband and I on a relaxing trip away. We were looking for something that was away from the hustle and bustle and Bon Bini was absolutely wonderful. Two cottages - one with the bedroom, one with kitchen, living area, and toilet. Outdoor shower which was really fun, And the VIEW. It's impossibly gorgeous. Surreal even. We spent a lot of time sitting at the table (you see in the first photo of the listing) and gazing out at the boats, water, and island beyond. In the evening, it's quiet and chill.
Emily was so kind, answering all of my questions prior to arrival, providing helpful tips, and even sending a video of how to find the cottage. St. John doesn't provide road signs or house numbers so navigation is a little tricky overall - but Emily made it SO easy. We even locked ourselves out during our stay and she had us back in in less than 5 minutes.
Coral Bay has a few restaurants, market, and small dock to catch excursions from. We ate at Rhumb Lines and Skinny Legs - very different experiences, but both great! We went to Lime Out (which you can see from the cottage), and it was a 5 minute boat ride from Coral Bay. Super easy and convenient - and FUN.
My biggest advice would be to rent a jeep. St. John overall has a lot of switch backs and rocky roads, especially if you want to adventure around the island. We had a car and it was ok, but next time we will level up for a jeep. It's about 20-25 minutes to get to the cottage from Cruz Bay and about 15 minutes from the Maho/Trunk Bay beaches - which were our favorite.
We really wanted our time at Bon Bini and in Coral Bay to be quiet and relaxing since this was a couples only trip for two exhausted parents of three kids. It was PERFECT for us and we can't wait to go back some day. Book this rental, you won't be disappointed.