Search Lower Sugarloaf Key Cottage Rentals

"We stayed in the sea shell cottage, perfect for two. The unit was clean and the grounds were beautiful. There is a grill and a flattop griddle you can use. We went out for most meals so we didn’t use them. Close to a ton a restaurants, good recommendations in the book Had a great time! Will be back"

"The location and views are great. It was a comfortable stay. There were some deferred maintenance items which were shared with the property manager. Completion of these items will greatly enhance the experience at the property and make it a '10' rating."

"This rental is in a perfect, peaceful location! We brought our paddleboards and fishing poles and enjoyed the Florida sun. Great getaway - we will definitely be back!"

"These are great older cottages. Not luxurious, great for fishing, relaxing away from the bustle of Key West but a short drive to all the fun. Local restaurants are great Tonio's was definitely our favorite. Lobster and local fish. Skewered shimp with rice and great sauce. We had a relaxing time "

"We really enjoyed our recent long weekend at the Seagull property! It started with an airport pickup from Wisi, who also picked up our bags after checkout so that we could walk around before our flight. And then he came and met us where we were to run us to the airport-it was fantastic! The property is great, albeit a 10-20 min walk to some places. That said, the quiet was great and the Tipsy Rooster across the street alwyas had great live music at night! It was a great fit for us, although...

"It is what it is, only wish the furniture was not worn out. "

"We really liked the location of this rental. It is situated in a quiet community, on the beautiful canal, and close to other things in the area. We did not spend a ton of time at the house due to family events but the property had everything we needed for our short weekend trip. The only reason I gave it a 4 star is because of the air conditioning rule. The house rules state you cannot turn the AC down lower than 75 degrees, which is not a comfortable setting. "

"Great location, loved the pool and outdoor patio"

"Easily walkable to most tourist attractions."

"This little cottage was perfect for our stay. Clean and comfortable. No frills but all essentials. Property manager gave very helpful clear directions to find the cottage. Would stay again. "

"We would highly recommend this rental. The host,Hope was so nice and recommended many highlights of the area to visit and restaurants.The owners, Glenn and Trina were also so friendly and accommodating to us. Very clean unit. Equipped with everything we needed. Heated pool was a nice added bonus."

"This property has all the items that you would expect in the kitchen and more. It was a wonderful time, sitting in the back, relaxing with coffee in the morning . Supper time around the outdoor table. Grilled fish on the barbecue. I would definitely go back."