The location of this property was absolutely amazing - its worth staying here for that alone. Right in the middle of Old Town, our farthest walk to anything we had planned was 25 min and shortest being mere minutes. As other reviews have stated it is not the most up to date place, but that is not something I am concerned about when basically only using a place to sleep and spend the rest of my time in the beautiful weather exploring. I do wish the bathroom would have had a fan as it did get pretty humid in that room when showering.
Another thing that is not necessarily a con, just something you should be aware of if you are looking to stay here is that because of the location it is not quiet or sound proof in any way. The layout has the bedroom right up next to the street and there are neighbors close on either side that you can hear very easily. Without intervention you can hear people walking by, conversations, scooters, trucks, cars, roosters (lol). We always bring a fairly loud white noise machine on vacation and kept the AC fan on at night so we were able to drown out the majority of the excess noise and had no problems, but if you didn't have either of those and are a light sleeper you will have a bad time.
Would definitely stay here again - awesome location, great place to stay when exploring Key West. Check in and check out were extremely smooth and communication with host was great.